Posts Tagged ‘Proust Metafors’

Just as…

January 7, 2010

Proust at every occasion will expand on a simple observation by comparing it to another he believes we must know. These examples come from the former prostitute Rachel’s poetry recital at the Princesse ‘s matinee.

But for the first few moments, just as when, in a trivial case in a low-court, we see a barrister advance, raise a toga’d arm in the air and start to speak in a threatening tone, we hardly dare look at our neighbours. For our immediate reaction is that this is a grotesque–but we cannot be sure that it is not in fact magnificent, so for the present we suspend judgement. (VI,457)

People looked at one another, not knowing what expression to put on their faces: a few badly mannered young things giggled audibly; everyone glanced at his neighbor with that stealthy glance which at a smart dinner-party, when you find beside your plate an unfamiliar implement, a lobster-fork or sugar-grinder perhaps, of which you know neither what it is for nor how to use it, you cast at some more authoritative guest in the hope that he will pick it up before you…(VI,457)

When the moment came to make a joke, she [Mme de Guermantes] would check herself for the same number of seconds as in the past, she would appear to hesitate, to have something within her that was struggling to emerge, but the joke, when at last it arrived, was pitifully feeble. But how few of her listeners noticed this! Because the procedure was the same they believed that the wit too had survived intact, like those people who, superstitiously attached to some particular make of confectionery, continue to order  their petits four from a certain shop without noticing that they have become almost uneatable. (VI,464)

 

Metaphor Time

December 28, 2009

In describing the feeling of happiness given by an unforced memory, the narrator is in a way providing the emotional power of the metaphor in art.

[The writer] can describe a scene by describing one after another the innumerable objects which at a given moment were present at a particular place, but truth will be attained by him only when he takes two different objects, state the connexion between them–a connexion analogous in the world of art to the unique connexion which in the world of science is provided by the law of  causality–and encloses them in the necessary links of a well-wrought  style; truth–and life  too–can be attained by us only when, by comparing a quality common to two sensations, we succeed in extracting their common essence and in reuniting them to each other, liberated from the  contingencies of time, within a metaphor. (VI,289)

His definition of metaphor is very similar to that of the unforced memory, which also escapes “the contingencies of time.”

But let a noise or a scent, once heard or once smelt, be heard or smelt again in the present and at the same time in the past, real without being actual, ideal without being abstract, and immediately the permanent and habitually concealed essence of things is liberated…(VI,264)

Metaphor and unforced memory both generate the happiness that comes from escaping time and from discovering the “concealed essense of things.”